Work Permit Refused Because the Officer Says You Cannot Do the Job? What IRCC Can and Cannot Require

Your employer interviewed you and offered you the job. Employment and Social Development Canada approved the Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA). Then IRCC refused the work permit, because the officer was not satisfied that you can perform the work.
That refusal comes from paragraph 200(3)(a) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR): an officer shall not issue a work permit if there are reasonable grounds to believe you are unable to perform the work sought. A positive LMIA does not bind the officer. But you are measured against the requirements of this job, as the LMIA, the offer and the National Occupational Classification (NOC) define them. The officer cannot invent a new one.
What the officer is actually testing
IRCC's instructions tell officers to check whether you meet the job requirements, including experience, education, language, training and any other element specified in the LMIA or the LMIA-exempt offer. The standard is low: reasonable grounds, not proof. It applies to every employer-specific work permit, with or without an LMIA, but not to open work permits.
Business owners face the same test. On a C10 significant benefit work permit or a C11, the question becomes whether you can run the business your plan describes, and your record in that field is the answer.
Required, usually required, may be required: the words that decide these files
Every NOC description lists employment requirements, and the verbs matter. For food service supervisors (NOC 62020), a college program in food service or several years of experience "are required", while secondary school is "usually required". For home support workers and caregivers (NOC 44101), training in care of the elderly and first aid "may be required".
An item that "is required" is a real condition, and an officer can hold you to it. So can anything your employer wrote into the LMIA or the offer. "Usually" and "may" describe what employers often or sometimes ask for, not conditions every worker must meet. An officer who refuses you for lacking an optional qualification your employer never asked for has written a new requirement into your job.
Officers cannot make up requirements: what the Federal Court has said
In decisions from 2025 and 2026, the Court set aside refusals where officers did exactly that: a caregiver refused for lacking training that was optional under the NOC and not required by the LMIA, and a flooring installer refused for not filing a language test that no rule demanded, where the officer also did not properly deal with the evidence filed.
It also upheld refusals where the requirement was real. A cook with more than ten years of experience had no proof of the secondary school education the LMIA expressly required. A food service supervisor applicant could not show the required education or experience. An applicant with about 19 years of experience did not show the English the job needed.
Read the two groups together. Experience does not replace a requirement that is really there. A requirement that is not there cannot be invented.
Language: where officers may look beyond the LMIA
IRCC's instructions tell officers not to limit their language assessment to the LMIA, while treating its language requirement as the employer's own assessment of the job. The officer can weigh the working conditions, the NOC description and any arrangements the employer has made for limited English or French, but not how you would manage daily life outside work. So a test is not automatically required. If the job runs on English, you have to show you have it. A test result is the clearest proof, and education or years of work in English can carry real weight too.
Express Entry works differently
For the Federal Skilled Worker Program and the Canadian Experience Class, IRCC's instructions say plainly that you do not need to meet the employment requirements in the NOC description. What counts is the work you did: the lead statement and a substantial number of the main duties, including all of the essential duties. The Federal Skilled Trades Program is the exception: there you must meet the NOC job requirements for your trade. I explain how to pick and defend a code in my guide to choosing the right NOC code for Express Entry.
Genuineness and qualifications meet in the same file
A genuineness refusal under subsection 200(5) of the IRPR is about the employer: whether the business is real, needs the role and can pay. I cover it in my article on job offers refused as not genuine. Your ability to do the job is a separate question, but the two meet. When your background fits the duties, it supports the employer's account of why it needs the role and why it chose you. When it does not, the officer asks why a real employer would hire you for this job, and a qualifications concern becomes a genuineness concern.
The evidence, in kind
The regulation does not prescribe documents, so you can be as specific and as creative as your history allows. The file that works matches every requirement to a piece of proof.
Reference letters: on letterhead, with dates, hours and duties in the employer's own words, signed by a supervisor. IRCC checks them, as I explain in how IRCC verifies work experience.
Proof the work happened: contracts, pay slips, tax and social security records.
Credentials: diplomas, transcripts, trade certificates, licences and training records for every required item.
Work product: a portfolio, photos of finished projects, client letters, or a trade test or trial shift documented by the employer.
The employer's letter: why it chose you, how it checked your skills, and any training it will provide.
If you have already been refused
Order the officer's notes (the GCMS notes), because the refusal letter rarely shows the reasoning, and compare the requirement applied with the LMIA, the offer and the exact NOC wording. If the officer used a requirement the job did not have, or ignored your evidence, reconsideration or judicial review in the Federal Court may fit. Do not wait for the notes to decide on the Court: you have 15 days after learning of a decision made in Canada, and 60 days for one made outside Canada. If the requirement was real and the proof was missing, a new application is often the better route. My guide to reconsideration requests covers that choice, and here is how I handle refusals and procedural fairness.
What I would do now
Open the NOC description for your code and mark each employment requirement as required, usually required or may be required.
Read the LMIA or the offer for every requirement your employer wrote in.
Match each requirement to a document before you apply, not after a refusal.
If you were refused, order the officer's notes at once and diary the Federal Court deadline.
If you want me to review your refusal or your application, you can book an online consultation. I work on flat fees. If a route does not fit your facts, I will tell you.
The articles on this site are general information, not legal advice, and reading them doesn't create a lawyer-client relationship. Immigration rules change often, so always consult a qualified Canadian immigration lawyer about your specific situation.



