Canada's Start-up Visa Program and Its Relationship with Corporate Law

For foreign entrepreneurs with innovative business ideas, Canada's Start-Up Visa (SUV) Program offers a unique pathway to permanent residency. This program is designed to attract dynamic business minds who can contribute to the Canadian economy by creating jobs and fostering innovation. However, navigating the intricate requirements of both immigration and corporate law is crucial for a successful application. This guide provides a detailed, up-to-date overview of the program, with a special focus on the corporate law intricacies that applicants must master.

Eligibility Criteria: The Foundation of Your Application

To be eligible for the Start-Up Visa Program, you must satisfy several key requirements:

• Qualifying Business: Your proposed business must be innovative, scalable, and capable of competing on a global stage. A key element is that it must be a new business; you generally cannot purchase an existing one to qualify.

  
  

• Letter of Support: You must secure a Letter of Support from a designated Canadian entity. These organizations are approved by the Canadian government and include venture capital funds, angel investor groups, and business incubators. This letter is the cornerstone of your application, signifying that a designated entity believes in your business concept's potential.

  
  

• Language Proficiency: You must demonstrate a minimum proficiency in either English or French, equivalent to the Canadian Language Benchmark (CLB) 5 in all four abilities: speaking, listening, reading, and writing.

  
  

• Settlement Funds: You must prove you have sufficient funds to support yourself and your dependents upon your arrival in Canada. The required amount varies based on family size and is updated annually by the Canadian government. These funds cannot be borrowed from another person.

The Corporate Law Maze: Structuring Your Start-Up for Success

Beyond the initial eligibility criteria, the corporate structure of your start-up is a critical component that is heavily scrutinized by both the designated organization and immigration officials. Here's a detailed breakdown of the corporate law requirements and what you need to be careful with:

Corporate Structure: Federal vs. Provincial Incorporation

A fundamental decision you'll face is whether to incorporate your business federally or provincially.

• Federal Incorporation (Canada Business Corporations Act - CBCA): This allows you to operate your business anywhere in Canada under the same name. It offers broader name protection. While you will still need to register your corporation in each province where you conduct business, a federal incorporation signals a national ambition, which can be viewed favorably in the context of the SUV program's goal of creating globally competitive companies.

  
  

• Provincial Incorporation: This limits your business operations to the specific province of incorporation. If you plan to operate in multiple provinces, you would need to register as an extra-provincial corporation in each, which can be cumbersome.

Recommendation for SUV Applicants: Federal incorporation is often the more strategic choice for SUV applicants as it aligns better with the program's expectation of creating a business with a national and international scope.

Share Structure: More Than Just Ownership Percentages

The share structure of your corporation is not merely a formality; it's a key indicator of your commitment and the legitimacy of your business venture. The government has specific, non-negotiable requirements:

• Applicant Ownership: Each applicant for the Start-Up Visa (up to five founders can apply together for one business) must hold at least 10% of the voting rights in the corporation.

  
  

• Combined Ownership: The applicants and the designated organization together must hold more than 50% of the total voting rights in the corporation.

Classes of Shares: You can issue different classes of shares (e.g., Class A voting shares, Class B non-voting shares). This can be a strategic way to distribute equity without diluting voting control. For instance, you could issue non-voting shares to initial employees or advisors. However, for the SUV program, the focus will be squarely on the distribution of voting shares.

What Can Go Wrong:

• Insufficient Voting Rights: A common mistake is focusing on the percentage of shares owned rather than the percentage of voting rights. If the share structure is complex, ensure that the 10% and 50% voting rights rules are clearly met and documented.

  
  

• "Artificial" Transactions: The case of an application being refused for being an "artificial transaction" highlights a critical point. The business structure and share distribution must be commercially reasonable and not solely for immigration purposes. Any arrangement that appears to be a "rent-a-stake" to meet the ownership requirements will be flagged and likely lead to refusal. For example, if an applicant has 10% of the voting shares but has no real involvement or influence in the company, this could be deemed artificial.

The Unanimous Shareholder Agreement (USA): Your Rulebook for Governance

A Unanimous Shareholder Agreement (USA) is a contract among the shareholders of a corporation. For a start-up with multiple founders, a well-drafted USA is essential.

Key Provisions for SUV Applicants in a USA:

• Roles and Responsibilities: Clearly define the roles, responsibilities, and active management duties of each founder. This is crucial for demonstrating that each applicant is "essential" to the business, a key consideration for the designated organization and immigration authorities.

  
  

• Vesting Schedules: While not a direct immigration requirement, including share vesting schedules in your USA is a standard and wise practice for start-ups. Vesting means that founders earn their shares over a period of time. This protects the company if a founder leaves prematurely.

  
  

• Intellectual Property (IP) Assignment: The USA should contain clauses that ensure any intellectual property developed by the founders related to the business is assigned to the corporation. This is critical for the valuation and long-term viability of the company.

  
  

• Dispute Resolution: Outline a clear process for resolving disagreements among founders.

  
  

• Shotgun Clause (Buy-Sell Agreement): This clause allows a shareholder to offer to buy the shares of another shareholder, who must either sell their shares or buy the offering shareholder's shares at the same price. This can be a mechanism to resolve deadlocks.

  
  

What Can Go Wrong:

• Lack of a USA: Proceeding without a USA is a significant risk. Disagreements are common in start-ups, and without a governing document, these can escalate and jeopardize the business and your immigration status.

  
  

• A Boilerplate USA: Using a generic template without tailoring it to the specific dynamics of your team and business can be ineffective. The agreement should reflect the unique contributions and expectations of each founder.

  
  

• Contradictory Clauses: Ensure the USA does not contain clauses that contradict the articles of incorporation or the requirements of the SUV program.

Intellectual Property: Protecting Your Most Valuable Asset

For many start-ups, intellectual property is their most valuable asset.

• Assignment to the Corporation: As mentioned, it is crucial to have all founders formally assign their relevant intellectual property to the newly formed Canadian corporation. This should be a legally binding agreement. Failure to do so can create ownership disputes down the line and may be a red flag for designated organizations who want to see that the company owns its core assets.

  
  

• Protection in Canada: Familiarize yourself with Canadian IP laws regarding patents, trademarks, and copyrights. The Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) is a valuable resource.

  
  

What Can Go Wrong:

• Ambiguous IP Ownership: If it's unclear who owns the IP, it can deter investment and create significant legal battles. Designated organizations will conduct due diligence on this.

  
  

• Failure to Secure Rights: Not taking the necessary steps to protect your IP in Canada can leave your innovations vulnerable.

Navigating the Process: What Applicants Need to Be Careful With

• Choosing the Right Designated Organization: Research and select a designated organization that is a good fit for your industry and stage of development. Their expertise and network can be invaluable.

  
  

• The Business Plan: Your business plan must be comprehensive, data-driven, and compelling. It should clearly articulate your innovative idea, market analysis, financial projections, and the expertise of your team.

  
  

• Active and Ongoing Management: The SUV program is not for passive investors. You must be able to demonstrate that you will be actively involved in the day-to-day management of the business from within Canada. Your role and responsibilities should be clearly defined.

  
  

• Consistency is Key: Ensure that the information you provide in your business plan, your application forms, and your shareholder agreements is consistent. Discrepancies can raise red flags.

  
  

• Professional Advice: Engage experienced legal and immigration professionals who specialize in the Start-Up Visa Program. The complexities of both corporate and immigration law require expert guidance. Attempting to navigate this process alone can lead to costly and time-consuming mistakes.

Potential Pitfalls: Where Things Can Go Wrong

Beyond the specific corporate law issues, other factors can lead to the refusal of your application:

• Misrepresentation: Providing false or misleading information is the fastest way to have your application refused and could lead to a ban on entering Canada.

  
  

• Incomplete Application: Ensure all forms are filled out completely and accurately, and all required documents are included.

  
  

• Failure to Demonstrate "Essential" Role: If there are multiple founders, each must be able to demonstrate why their presence in Canada is essential for the business's success. If one essential founder is deemed inadmissible, the entire group's application may be refused.

  
  

• The "Genuineness" of the Business: Immigration officers will assess whether the primary purpose of the business is to be a viable, profitable enterprise or simply a vehicle for immigration. Your passion, expertise, and the commercial viability of your idea must be evident.

  
  

In conclusion, Canada's Start-Up Visa Program presents a remarkable opportunity. However, success hinges on a meticulous approach that gives equal weight to both the immigration and corporate law requirements. By carefully structuring your corporation, formalizing relationships through a robust shareholder agreement, and presenting a compelling and genuine business case, you can significantly increase your chances of turning your entrepreneurial dream into a Canadian reality.

—o—

About the Author

I’m Ahmet Faruk Ocak, a Canadian immigration lawyer and the founder of Blacksy Immigration Law Firm 🌊. 

At Blacksy, we specialize in providing honest, straightforward, and tailored immigration solutions to individuals and businesses worldwide. Our brand promise is simple: no unnecessary fuss, no false hopes, and no empty promises—just realistic, reliable guidance to help you achieve your immigration goals.

Whether you’re expanding your business to Canada, transferring top talent, or planning your future here, we’re here to guide you with precision, transparency, and care.

Visit us at www.blacksyimmigration.com to learn more or to start your journey.