Beyond the Business Plan: Why Technical Strategy is Key to Intra-Company Transfer Success

For global businesses eyeing the Canadian market, the Intra-Company Transfer (ICT) program is a vital tool. It allows established multinational companies to relocate key personnel to a new or existing Canadian operation, fostering international growth and expansion. On the surface, the logic seems simple: a valuable employee from your foreign company moves to your Canadian one. However, a 2025 Federal Court decision reveals a critical truth—a successful business plan is not enough. Success in the ICT stream hinges on a deep, technical, and proactive legal strategy that aligns with Canada's strict definitions.

Anatomy of a Refusal: A Case Study in Complexity

A recent judicial review before the Federal Court illustrates this point perfectly. The case involved an entrepreneur who was the majority shareholder of a successful foreign company. The goal was to launch a new enterprise in Canada and transfer the entrepreneur to lead it, applying for a work permit under the ICT program.

The entire application rested on proving the foreign and Canadian companies had a "qualifying relationship," which is essential to meeting the definition of a multinational company (MNC) eligible for this program. The applicant claimed the two businesses were "affiliates".

This is where the application unravelled. Under Canadian immigration guidelines, for two companies to be considered "affiliates" in this context, they must be "one of two legal entities, owned and controlled by the same group of individuals, each individual owning and controlling approximately the same share or proportion of each company".

The visa officer closely examined the ownership structures presented in the application:

• The Foreign Company: Was owned by a group of three individuals with differing share percentages.
  
  

• The Canadian Company: Was owned 100% by the principal applicant alone.
  
  
  

The conclusion was decisive. The companies were not owned by the "same group of individuals". This single discrepancy made it impossible to meet the strict definition of an affiliate. As a result, the officer was not satisfied that the required multinational relationship existed, and the application was refused12. The Federal Court later upheld this decision as reasonable, noting that the onus is on the applicant to prove every element of the program is met.

Why a Deeper Strategy is Non-Negotiable

This case provides crucial lessons on the hidden complexities of the ICT program and the need for high-quality, strategic work:

1. The Foundational Multinational Requirement: The ICT program is not simply for any international business. It is specifically designed to enhance mobility within a genuine multinational corporation. The burden of proof is entirely on the applicant to demonstrate that their corporate structure fits one of Canada's precise definitions of an MNC—be it a parent, subsidiary, branch, or affiliate relationship. This is not a guideline; it is a fundamental pillar of the program.
   
   

2. Corporate Structure Must Precede the Application: The fatal flaw in this case existed before the immigration forms were even filled out. The ownership structure of the new Canadian company made it ineligible from its inception. A winning strategy involves a proactive approach: analyzing the ICT program's legal requirements first, and then carefully structuring the Canadian and foreign entities to ensure they are perfectly aligned with those requirements.

   
   

3. The High Stakes of a Technical Error: A refusal has significant consequences. In this instance, the denial of the main work permit directly resulted in the refusal of the accompanying applications for the applicant's spouse and children, as the purpose of their travel was no longer valid. This domino effect underscores the need for meticulous, error-free preparation.
   
   
   

The Hallmarks of a Quality Application

To navigate these complexities, a successful ICT application must be built on a foundation of quality work and strategic insight. This includes:

• Meticulous Legal Alignment: Ensuring the corporate ownership and control structures are not just similar, but identical in a way that satisfies the specific wording of the immigration guidelines.
  
  
  

• Strategic Business Planning: Crafting a business plan that does more than prove market viability. It must also serve as a core piece of evidence, clearly articulating and reinforcing the qualifying relationship between the entities and the overall benefit to Canada.
  
  
  

• Ironclad Evidentiary Support: Compiling a clear, detailed, and unambiguous body of evidence that preemptively answers any questions an officer might have about the multinational structure and the applicant's eligibility.

Your ambition to expand into Canada deserves a strategy as robust as your business. The Intra-Company Transfer program is an excellent vehicle for growth, but its path is unforgiving of technical missteps. Don't let a preventable error in your corporate structure derail your goals.

Contact our firm to develop a comprehensive legal strategy for your business immigration needs. We specialize in managing the complexities of the ICT program to build high-quality, successful applications from the ground up.

—o—

About the Author

I’m Ahmet Faruk Ocak, a Canadian immigration lawyer and the founder of Blacksy Immigration Law Firm 🌊. 

At Blacksy, we specialize in providing honest, straightforward, and tailored immigration solutions to individuals and businesses worldwide. Our brand promise is simple: no unnecessary fuss, no false hopes, and no empty promises—just realistic, reliable guidance to help you achieve your immigration goals.

Whether you’re expanding your business to Canada, transferring top talent, or planning your future here, we’re here to guide you with precision, transparency, and care.

Visit us at www.blacksyimmigration.com to learn more or to start your journey.