Asset Purchase vs. Share Purchase: A Critical Choice for Immigrant Entrepreneurs Acquiring Canadian Businesses

For international entrepreneurs looking to make Canada their new home by acquiring an existing Canadian business, one of the most fundamental decisions lies in how the transaction is structured: as an asset purchase or a share purchase. This choice carries profound legal, financial, and operational consequences, and critically, it can significantly influence the success of your Canadian business immigration application. Understanding these differences is not just a matter of good business practice; it's essential for a smoother immigration journey.

This article delves into the distinctions between asset and share purchases, explores their respective advantages, and, most importantly, analyzes their impact on pathways for business immigration to Canada.

Defining the Deal: Asset Purchase vs. Share Purchase

First, let's clarify the two primary structures for acquiring a business:

• Asset Purchase: In an asset purchase, the buyer's company acquires specific, identified assets from the seller's business. These can range from tangible assets like equipment, inventory, and real estate, to intangible assets such as intellectual property, customer lists, and goodwill. Importantly, the buyer also chooses which, if any, liabilities to assume. The seller's corporate entity remains separate and is not part of the acquisition.

  
  

  • Immigration Context: For immigrant entrepreneurs new to Canada, this often involves establishing a new Canadian corporation ("Newco") that then purchases these assets to operate the target business activity.

    
    

• Share Purchase: In a share purchase, the buyer acquires the shares of the company that owns the business. This means the buyer takes ownership of the entire corporate entity, including all its assets, existing contracts, permits, and, crucially, all its liabilities – whether known or unknown, historical or current. The business continues to operate within the same legal entity, now under new ownership.

  
  

  • Immigration Context: The immigrant entrepreneur effectively steps into the shoes of the previous owner of an ongoing Canadian corporation.

Core Differences & Advantages for the Immigrant Buyer

The decision between an asset and a share purchase will shape nearly every aspect of the acquisition and its aftermath. Here are key considerations for the immigrant buyer:

1. Assumption of Liabilities:

• Asset Purchase Advantage: A primary benefit is that the buyer generally does not automatically inherit the seller's past general liabilities, unless specifically agreed upon in the purchase agreement or imposed by law (e.g., certain environmental liabilities tied to acquired land, or obligations to unionized employees if applicable). This allows for a "cleaner" acquisition, reducing the risk of unforeseen debts or legal disputes from the seller's operational history.

  
  

• Share Purchase Consideration: The buyer inherits all existing and potential liabilities of the acquired company. This includes all debts, contractual obligations, tax arrears, ongoing or potential litigation, and employee-related claims. Extensive and meticulous due diligence is non-negotiable to identify and assess these inherited risks.

  
  

2. Continuity of Contracts, Licenses, and Permits:

• Asset Purchase Consideration: Contracts (e.g., leases, supplier agreements, client contracts), licenses, and permits held by the seller’s company typically do not automatically transfer to the buyer's new entity in an asset purchase. The buyer will usually need to seek formal assignment and obtain consent from third parties (landlords, licensors, contracting parties). This process can be lengthy, and there's a risk that some crucial agreements may not be assignable or may require renegotiation on less favorable terms.

  
  

• Share Purchase Advantage: Because the corporate entity itself is being acquired, its existing contracts, licenses, and permits generally remain in force and continue without interruption. This often leads to smoother operational continuity, a factor that can be viewed positively in an immigration context as it demonstrates an ongoing, stable business operation. However, some key contracts may contain "change of control" clauses that could be triggered by the sale of shares, requiring notification or consent.

  
  

3. Treatment of Existing Employees:

• Asset Purchase Flexibility & Responsibility: In an asset purchase, the buyer's company can choose which of the seller's employees it wishes to offer new employment to. This requires new employment agreements. Severance pay and other termination obligations for employees not hired by the buyer typically remain the responsibility of the seller. However, buyers must be aware that under Canadian employment law, including provincial Employment Standards Acts (like Ontario's) and common law principles, employee seniority for certain purposes (like statutory notice, severance, and vacation, or common law reasonable notice) might be deemed continuous even if they sign a new contract with the buyer's company, especially if there's no significant break in their employment. This is a complex area where legal counsel is vital.

  
  

• Share Purchase Continuity & Obligation: The employment relationships between the target company and its employees continue automatically under the new ownership. The buyer inherits all current employees along with their existing terms of employment, accrued benefits, and recognized seniority. If the new owner later decides to dismiss employees, the acquired company (now owned by the buyer) will be responsible for all associated termination costs, including severance pay.

  
  

4. Key Tax Implications for the Buyer:

Tax implications are multifaceted and demand expert advice. However, for a buyer, some of the most impactful differences include:

• Goods and Services Tax/Harmonized Sales Tax (GST/HST):

  
  

  • Asset Purchase: The purchase of business assets is generally a taxable supply subject to GST/HST. If the buyer acquires all or substantially all of the assets necessary to carry on the business, and both buyer and seller are GST/HST registrants, they can jointly file an election (Form GST44) to have the transaction occur without GST/HST being payable. If GST/HST is paid, the buyer can typically claim Input Tax Credits (ITCs) if they are a registrant making taxable supplies.

    
    

  • Share Purchase: The sale of shares is classified as a financial service and is generally exempt from GST/HST.

    
    

• Capital Cost Allowance (CCA) – "Stepped-Up Basis":

  
  

  • Asset Purchase Advantage: This is often a significant tax advantage. The buyer can allocate the total purchase price among the various depreciable assets acquired (e.g., equipment, buildings, goodwill). This allows the buyer's company to claim CCA (tax depreciation) on a "stepped-up" basis, meaning based on the fair market value paid for those assets. This can result in higher CCA deductions and lower taxable income in future years.

    
    

  • Share Purchase Consideration: When shares are purchased, the underlying assets within the acquired corporation retain their existing tax values (Undepreciated Capital Cost or UCC). The buyer does not get to "step up" the tax basis of these assets to reflect the price paid for the shares. Consequently, future CCA claims will be based on these potentially lower historical costs.

    
    

• Tax Attributes (e.g., Losses):

  
  

  • Asset Purchase: The buyer's company generally does not acquire the seller's corporate tax history, such as accumulated tax losses or other tax pools. These remain with the selling corporation.

    
    

  • Share Purchase: The acquired corporation continues with its existing tax attributes, including any available non-capital losses. However, specific "acquisition of control" (AOC) rules under the Income Tax Act (Canada) can restrict or eliminate the ability to utilize these pre-acquisition losses against future income.

    
    

The Crucial Link: Purchase Structure and Your Canadian Immigration Success

For prospective business immigrants, the choice of purchase structure is a cornerstone of their immigration strategy. It directly affects how key criteria for programs like the C11 work permit (for entrepreneurs and self-employed individuals) and Provincial Nominee Programs (PNPs) for entrepreneurs are met and assessed.

General Immigration Considerations:

Establishing a New Entity vs. Acquiring an Existing One:

• An asset purchase (especially by a new immigrant forming a Canadian company to buy assets) is generally viewed by immigration authorities as "establishing a new business" or, if the buyer’s Canadian company already existed and is making the purchase, "expanding an existing business." The assessment will heavily rely on the buyer's comprehensive business plan, detailing how the new entity will utilize the acquired assets to become viable, profitable, create jobs for Canadians or permanent residents, and provide a "significant benefit" to Canada.

  
  

• A share purchase is a clear "acquisition of an existing business." The target company's operational history, existing financials, employee base, and contracts provide a tangible foundation. The buyer’s plan to manage, sustain, and grow this existing enterprise will be critical.

  
  

Suitability for Key Immigration Pathways:

1. C11 or C10 Work Permit (Entrepreneur/Self-Employed Work Permit): This pathway allows foreign nationals who can demonstrate they will build or operate a business in Canada that will yield significant economic, social, or cultural benefits, or opportunities for Canadians, to obtain a work permit without needing a Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA). A key requirement is significant ownership (typically at least 51%) of the Canadian business.

   
   

   • Asset Purchase: The applicant's new (or existing) Canadian company, in which they hold controlling interest, purchases the assets. The entrepreneur work permit application must persuasively demonstrate how this company, using the acquired assets, will establish and operate a qualifying business. The strength of the business plan, financial projections, and evidence of the applicant’s ability to execute the plan are paramount.

     
     

   • Share Purchase: The applicant acquires a controlling interest in an existing Canadian operating company. The entrepreneur application will focus on the viability and ongoing operations of this acquired company, coupled with the applicant's active management role and plans for its future development and the significant benefit it will bring. The established nature of the business can be advantageous if it's healthy and compliant.

     
     

2. Provincial Nominee Programs (PNP) – Entrepreneur Streams: Most Canadian provinces offer PNP streams for entrepreneurs who wish to establish or purchase a business and settle in that province. These programs typically have minimum requirements for personal net worth, business investment, business or management experience, job creation, and active management of the business. For example, BC's Entrepreneur Stream, Nova Scotia's Entrepreneur Stream, or New Brunswick's Entrepreneur Stream.

   
   

   • Asset Purchase:

     
     

     • Investment: The amount invested by the applicant's Canadian company in qualifying assets (as defined by the specific PNP) will be assessed against the program's minimum investment threshold.

       
       

     • Business Plan: A detailed and credible business plan is crucial, outlining how the acquired assets will be used by the applicant's company to create a successful enterprise that meets the PNP’s economic objectives (e.g., job creation in targeted sectors, innovation).

       
       

     • Job Creation: The applicant's company will be responsible for creating the required number of jobs for Canadians or permanent residents.

       
       

   • Share Purchase:

     
     

     • Investment: The fair market value of the shares purchased will be considered the investment. Many PNPs have specific criteria for purchasing an existing business, such as the business having been operational for a minimum period, requirements to maintain terms for existing Canadian employees, or the need for an exploratory visit.

       
       

     • Due Diligence is Vital: The financial health, legal and tax compliance, and operational history of the target company will be intensely scrutinized by PNP authorities. Any discovered non-compliance or instability can derail the application.

       
       

     • Continuity & Growth: Applicants usually need to demonstrate how they will not only sustain the existing business but also improve its performance, expand its operations, or create additional jobs.

Key Immigration Criteria Impacted by Purchase Structure:

• Business Viability & Genuineness: With an asset purchase into a new company, viability hinges on a strong business plan and the income-generating potential of the assets. For a share purchase, the target company's existing track record is a key factor, alongside the applicant's strategic vision for its future.

  
  

• Job Creation/Retention: In an asset purchase, the buyer's new company creates jobs by hiring staff. In a share purchase, existing jobs are typically inherited, and PNPs often mandate their retention plus the creation of new positions.

  
  

• Active Management & Control: Regardless of the structure, the applicant must prove they will be actively involved in the day-to-day management of the Canadian business and hold a controlling interest in the Canadian entity that operates it.

  
  

• Significant Benefit to Canada: The chosen structure must facilitate the demonstration of benefits such as job creation, innovation, introduction of new products/services, or development in regional areas.

Due Diligence: A Non-Negotiable Step for Immigrant Buyers

Thorough due diligence is critical for any business acquisition, but for immigrant entrepreneurs, it carries the added weight of ensuring the business and the transaction align with immigration program requirements.

• For Asset Purchases:

  
  

  • Verify the condition, fair market value, and clear legal title of all assets being acquired.

  • Understand any specific liabilities being assumed, particularly those that might attach to assets (e.g., environmental contamination of land).

  • Confirm that the acquired assets can realistically support the business plan submitted for immigration purposes and meet projected job creation targets.

    
    

• For Share Purchases (Requires Extensive Due Diligence):

  
  

  • Financials: Scrutinize several years of financial statements, tax filings (corporate income tax, GST/HST, payroll), and internal accounting records. This verifies the business's profitability, cash flow, and ability to support the applicant and meet PNP viability criteria.

    
    

  • Legal & Compliance: Investigate any pending or past litigation, ensure compliance with all relevant federal and provincial regulations, confirm good standing with tax authorities, and review employment contracts and practices for compliance with labour laws. Inheriting non-compliance can have severe consequences for the business and the immigration application.

    
    

  • Operational: Review all material contracts (leases, key supplier/customer agreements), assess the condition of operational assets, and understand customer relationships.

    
    

  • Employees: Verify the number of existing Canadian employees, their roles, tenure, and payroll records, especially if claiming points for existing jobs under a PNP or relying on current staff for operational continuity critical to the immigration business plan.

Strategic Considerations & Common Pitfalls

• Risk Mitigation: Asset purchases can offer better protection from the seller's historical liabilities, which can be particularly attractive to newcomers. Share purchases offer operational continuity but carry the risk of inheriting the target company's entire past.

  
  

  
  

• Program Alignment: Carefully analyze the specific requirements and preferences of your chosen immigration program. Some PNPs may have guidelines that slightly favor one approach over another in certain contexts (e.g., revitalizing an existing local business vs. establishing a new innovative venture).

  
  

• Transaction Complexity: Asset purchases can be more complex in terms of legal documentation (individual transfer agreements for numerous assets). Share purchases are often simpler transactionally (transfer of shares) but demand far more comprehensive due diligence.

  
  

• Common Pitfalls for Immigrant Entrepreneurs:

  
  

  • Insufficient Due Diligence: Especially failing to uncover financial instability or compliance issues that later affect immigration eligibility.

    
    

  • Weak or Generic Business Plan: Not clearly demonstrating how the acquired business (under either structure) will be viable and meet specific immigration criteria (e.g., job creation, significant benefit).

    
    

  • Overpaying for the Business: Letting immigration objectives overshadow sound business valuation.

    
    

  • Misunderstanding Job Creation/Retention Requirements: These are often strictly enforced by immigration authorities.

    
    

  • Not Demonstrating Active Management: Immigration programs require genuine involvement, not passive investment.

Making the Right Choice for Your Canadian Future

The decision to structure your Canadian business acquisition as an asset purchase or a share purchase is a critical one with long-term consequences for both your business success and your immigration journey. There is no universally "better" option; the optimal path depends on the unique circumstances of the target business, your personal and financial situation, your tolerance for risk, and, crucially, the specific requirements and nuances of your chosen Canadian immigration program.

Engaging experienced legal counsel who understands both Canadian corporate/commercial law and business immigration intricacies is vital. A knowledgeable lawyer can help you analyze the pros and cons of each structure in your specific context, guide you through the due diligence process with an eye on immigration requirements, and help ensure your acquisition is structured to best support your entrepreneurial ambitions and your dream of making Canada your permanent home.

—o—

About the Author

I’m Ahmet Faruk Ocak, a Canadian immigration lawyer and the founder of Blacksy Immigration Law Firm 🌊. 

At Blacksy, we specialize in providing honest, straightforward, and tailored immigration solutions to individuals and businesses worldwide. Our brand promise is simple: no unnecessary fuss, no false hopes, and no empty promises—just realistic, reliable guidance to help you achieve your immigration goals.

Whether you’re expanding your business to Canada, transferring top talent, or planning your future here, we’re here to guide you with precision, transparency, and care.

Visit us at www.blacksyimmigration.com to learn more or to start your journey.